Our target audience will be attorneys, mostly at large and prestigious law firms in some of the biggest cities (NYC, LA, Chicago, DC, etc.) who are bored with their day-to-day life. They will come here for excitement. They will be between 25-50 years old, but the sweet spot will be with attorneys 25-40. Law students may also be frequent visitors, but we will target them less.
These are very intelligent people so they will want to see a professional looking site, with a fun/gossip slant because they are here for entertainment. It will be a mix of men and women, obviously more on the tech-savvy side of the population.
We are also holding a contest for a new website layout/design, so they will both be launched at the same time.
I like the idea of a newspaper/typewriter font for the word "Judged" just as one option or as inspiration. Very black/white or gavel-fueled.